Date
10th April 2019
Venue
Kensington Suite, Millennium Gloucester Hotel, London
Present members
Mark Lambert Chair
Rebecca Randell Deputy Chair
Rob Anderson
Jess Baxendale
Alex Bottle
Dawn Craig
Lorna Gibson
Julie Hankin
Kerryn Husk
Doreen Joseph
Alison Ledward
Brendan McCormack
Abeda Mulla Arrived at 1.30pm on day 1
Catherine Pope
Sarah Purdy
Karen Ritchie
Alison Thompson
Catherine Walshe
Robert West
Apologies Mo Aye
Tim Freeman
Sarah Finer
Jean Simpson
Peta Stross (for day 1)
Rhiannon Phillips
Secretariat
Stephanie Garfield-Birkbeck
Kevin Campbell
Abi Chalk
Becs Moran
Lisa Stockwell
In attendance
Nil
Observers
Luke Wainwright, Research & Innovation Coordinator – NHS England
Quoracy information
Voting members: 24 (Quorum = 16)
Voting members present at meeting: 18 (75%)
Researcher-led Stage 1 Proposals: 18/136 Standard Open Call
NIHR128740 Forecasting non-elective activity in Acute NHS Trusts – Dr Maria Redaniel
The proposal was discussed by the Prioritisation Committee and declined.
Chair: Mark Lambert
Conflicts: Sarah Purdy
Decision: Declined
NIHR128731 The role, contribution and impact of patients and the public in the implementation of evidence into practice in health and social care – Professor Sophie Staniszewska
The proposal was discussed by the Prioritisation Committee and declined.
Chair: Mark Lambert
Conflicts: Brendan McCormack
Decision: Declined
NIHR128355 An evidence-based evaluation of the effectiveness and appropriateness of a new rapid diagnostic pathway for patients with non specific symptoms of cancer – Dr Jason Oke
The proposal was discussed by the Prioritisation Committee and shortlisted.
Chair: Mark Lambert
Conflicts: Catherine Pope
Decision: Shortlisted
NIHR128364 Inter-CEPt: Intervening to eliminate the centre effect variation in home dialysis use – Professor Simon Davies
The proposal was discussed by the Prioritisation Committee and shortlisted.
Chair: Mark Lambert
Conflicts: None
Decision: Shortlisted
NIHR128127 Babies at Greater Risk of Overweight (BabyGRO): evaluation of a digital intervention to identify infants at higher risk of overweight in health visiting practice – Professor Sarah Redsell
The proposal was discussed by the Prioritisation Committee and declined.
Chair: Mark Lambert
Conflicts: None
Decision: Declined
NIHR128369 Improving the accuracy of risk of psychosis prediction using a prediction model (P-risk) based on primary care consultation data: An implementation study – Dr Sarah Sullivan
The proposal was discussed by the Prioritisation Committee and declined.
Chair: Mark Lambert
Conflicts: Sarah Purdy and Catherine Walshe
Decision: Declined
NIHR128373 Can CBT for psychosis be delivered by a psychology graduate workforce? A non-inferiority trial – Professor Anthony Morrison
The proposal was discussed by the Prioritisation Committee and declined.
Chair: Mark Lambert
Conflicts: Dawn Craig
Decision: Declined
NIHR128852 Real Bereavement Talk: Describing and improving bereavement support through video-based research and training – Dr Marco Pino
The proposal was discussed by the Prioritisation Committee and declined.
Chair: Mark Lambert
Conflicts: None
Decision: Declined
NIHR128627 An analysis of interaction in midwife-moderated social-media support groups – Dr John Chatwin
The proposal was discussed by the Prioritisation Committee and declined.
Chair: Rebecca Randell
Conflicts: None
Decision: Declined
NIHR128714 A formative evaluation of the impact of Care Coordinators in relation to the experiences of older people and their informal carers in accessing, navigating and coordinating health and social care services in England – Dr Sophie Sarre
The proposal was discussed by the Prioritisation Committee and declined.
Chair: Rebecca Randell
Conflicts: Catherine Pope
Decision: Declined
NIHR128873 Glioccova: Care, costs, outcomes, variations and admission in patients with malignant glioma in England – Dr Matthew Williams
The proposal was discussed by the Prioritisation Committee and shortlisted.
Chair: Mark Lambert
Conflicts: Alex Bottle
Decision: Shortlisted
NIHR128705 Stakeholder involvement in systematic reviews (“ACTIVE 2”) – Dr Alex Pollock
The proposal was discussed by the Prioritisation Committee and declined.
Chair: Mark Lambert
Conflicts: Catherine Pope
Decision: Declined
NIHR128846 A national study of practice patterns in renal services in the identification and management of depression in people with chronic kidney disease – Professor Ken Farrington
The proposal was discussed by the Prioritisation Committee and declined.
Chair: Mark Lambert
Conflicts: None
Decision: Declined
NIHR128700 Mixed methods evaluation of a co-produced, functions-based, national quality improvement initiative to improve the health and wellbeing of individuals affected by a common mental health condition (Co-Improve) – Professor Jonathan Bisson
The proposal was discussed by the Prioritisation Committee and declined.
Chair: Mark Lambert
Conflicts: None
Decision: Declined
NIHR128726 Co-designing and testing the feasibility of a complex intervention to improve wellbeing and psychosocial outcomes for men with a dual diagnosis of Klinefelter’s syndrome and infertility – Dr Esmée Hanna
The proposal was discussed by the Prioritisation Committee and declined.
Chair: Mark Lambert
Conflicts: None
Decision: Declined
NIHR128802 Treating patients' sleep problems on acute psychiatric hospital wards to quicken recovery and reduce admission duration: a stepped-wedge, cluster-randomised controlled trial to evaluate the effects of a ward sleep treatment package on admission lengths, clinical outcomes, and economic costs – Professor Daniel Freeman
The proposal was discussed by the Prioritisation Committee and declined.
Chair: Mark Lambert
Conflicts: Alex Bottle and Robert West
Decision: Declined
HS&DR (Researcher-led) Prioritisation Committee Meeting Minutes
Date
11th April 2019
Venue
Kensington Suite, Millennium Gloucester Hotel, London
Present members
Mark Lambert Chair
Rebecca Randell Deputy Chair
Rob Anderson
Alex Bottle
Dawn Craig
Lorna Gibson
Julie Hankin
Kerryn Husk
Doreen Joseph
Alison Ledward
Brendan McCormack
Abeda Mulla
Catherine Pope
Sarah Purdy
Peta Stross
Alison Thompson
Catherine Walshe
Robert West
Apologies Mo Aye
Tim Freeman
Sarah Finer
Jean Simpson
Jess Baxendale (for day 2 only)
Karen Ritchie (for day 2 only)
Rhiannon Phillips
Secretariat
Stephanie Garfield-Birkbeck
Kevin Campbell
Suzy Hopper
Abi Chalk
Lisa Stockwell
In attendance
Nil
Observers
Nil
Quoracy information
Voting members: 24 (Quorum = 16)
Voting members present at meeting: 17 (71%)
Day 2 Prioritisation Committee Minutes
Researcher-led Stage 1 Proposals: 18/136 Standard Open Call Cont.
NIHR128877 Understanding the imPlications of Screening and Triage on Mental Health REcovery After Mass trauma events (UPSTREAM) – Professor Paul French
The proposal was discussed by the Prioritisation Committee and shortlisted.
Chair: Mark Lambert
Conflicts: Dawn Craig
Decision: Shortlisted
NIHR128773 uSing rolE-substitutioN In care hOmes to improve oRal health (SENIOR) – Professor Paul Brocklehurst
The proposal was discussed by the Prioritisation Committee and shortlisted.
Chair: Mark Lambert
Conflicts: None
Decision: Shortlisted
NIHR128701 Development of a care pathway to address complex health and social care needs of older people who use drugs using candidacy theory and a co-production approach – Professor Catriona Matheson
The proposal was discussed by the Prioritisation Committee and declined.
Chair: Mark Lambert
Conflicts: Dawn Craig
Decision: Declined
NIHR128575 A randomised controlled trial evaluating the long-term effectiveness of Serenity Integrating Mentoring (SIM) compared to management as usual (MAU) – Dr Peter Fonagy
The proposal was discussed by the Prioritisation Committee and declined.
Chair: Mark Lambert
Conflicts: None
Decision: Declined
NIHR128839 Optimising the use of National Clinical Audits across the NHS to improve patient outcomes – Dr Grazia Antonacci
The proposal was discussed by the Prioritisation Committee and declined.
Chair: Mark Lambert
Conflicts: Alex Bottle
Decision: Declined
NIHR128365 Using evidence on public preferences for prioritisation to support local commissioning in the NHS: Development and validation of the Public Preferences and Priorities (PPP) evidence-based decision tool – Professor Jennifer Whitty
The proposal was discussed by the Prioritisation Committee and declined.
Chair: Mark Lambert
Conflicts: None
Decision: Declined
NIHR128777 Defining and Embedding a Common Mental Health Dataset in all UK Clinical Trials – Professor Kathryn Abel
The proposal was discussed by the Prioritisation Committee and declined.
Chair: Mark Lambert
Conflicts: Dawn Craig
Decision: Declined
NIHR128349 The use of locum doctors in the NHS: understanding and improving the safety and quality of care – Professor Kieran Walshe
The proposal was discussed by the Prioritisation Committee and shortlisted.
Chair: Mark Lambert
Conflicts: Catherine Walshe
Decision: Shortlisted
Researcher-led Stage 1 Proposals: 18/153 Management of Chronic Pain Theme Call
NIHR128704 Chronic pain self-management in context: Identifying the impact of life-context on engagement with self-management – Professor Karen Rodham
The proposal was discussed by the Prioritisation Committee and declined.
Chair: Mark Lambert
Conflicts: None
Decision: Declined
NIHR128671 A systematic review and meta-ethnography of how children with chronic non-cancer pain and their families experience and understand their condition, pain services and treatments – Dr Emma France
The proposal was discussed by the Prioritisation Committee and shortlisted.
Chair: Mark Lambert
Conflicts: Brendan McCormack, Catherine Pope and Dawn Craig
Decision: Shortlisted
NIHR128744 Clinical and cost effectiveness of an intervention to facilitate patient-led follow-on support groups (FSG) to maintain effects of pain management programmes (PMP) – Dr Penny Whiting
The proposal was discussed by the Prioritisation Committee and declined.
Chair: Mark Lambert
Conflicts: Sarah Purdy
Decision: Declined
Summary
Researcher-led Stage 1 Proposals: 18/136 Standard Open Call
NIHR128740 Forecasting non-elective activity in Acute NHS Trusts – Dr Maria Redaniel Declined
NIHR128731 The role, contribution and impact of patients and the public in the implementation of evidence into practice in health and social care – Professor Sophie Staniszewska Decline
NIHR128355 An evidence-based evaluation of the effectiveness and Appropriateness of a new rapid diagnostic pathway for patients with non-specific symptoms of cancer – Dr Jason Oke Shortlisted
NIHR128364 Inter-CEPt: Intervening to eliminate the centre effect variation in home dialysis use – Professor Simon Davies Shortlisted
NIHR128127 Babies at Greater Risk of Overweight (BabyGRO): evaluation of a digital intervention to identify infants at higher risk of overweight in health visiting practice – Professor Sarah Redsell Declined
NIHR128369 Improving the accuracy of risk of psychosis prediction using a prediction model (P-risk) based on primary care consultation data: An implementation study – Dr Sarah Sullivan Declined
NIHR128373 Can CBT for psychosis be delivered by a psychology graduate workforce? A non-inferiority trial – Professor Anthony Morrison Declined
NIHR128852 Real Bereavement Talk: Describing and improving bereavement support through video-based research and training – Dr Marco Pino Declined
NIHR128627 An analysis of interaction in midwife-moderated social-media support groups – Dr John Chatwin Declined
NIHR128714 A formative evaluation of the impact of Care Coordinators in relation to the experiences of older people and their informal carers in accessing, navigating and coordinating health and social care services in England – Dr Sophie Sarre Declined
NIHR128873 Glioccova: Care, costs, outcomes, variations and admission in patients with malignant glioma in England – Dr Matthew Williams Shortlisted
NIHR128705 Stakeholder involvement in systematic reviews (“ACTIVE 2”) – DrAlex Pollock Declined
NIHR128846 A national study of practice patterns in renal services in the identification and management of depression in people with chronic kidney disease – Professor Ken Farrington Declined
NIHR128700 Mixed methods evaluation of a co-produced, functions-based, national quality improvement initiative to improve the health and wellbeing of individuals affected by a common mental health
condition (Co-Improve) – Professor Jonathan Bisson Declined
NIHR128726 Co-designing and testing the feasibility of a complex intervention to improve wellbeing and psychosocial outcomes for men with a dual
diagnosis of Klinefelter’s syndrome and infertility – Dr Esmée Hanna Declined
NIHR128802 Treating patients' sleep problems on acute psychiatric hospital wards to quicken recovery and reduce admission duration: a stepped-wedge, cluster-randomised controlled trial to evaluate the effects of a ward sleep treatment package on admission lengths, clinical outcomes, and economic costs – Professor Daniel Freeman Declined
NIHR128877 Understanding the imPlications of Screening and Triage on Mental Health REcovery After Mass trauma events (UPSTREAM) – Professor Paul French Shortlisted
NIHR128773 uSing rolE-substitutioN In care hOmes to improve oRal health (SENIOR) – Professor Paul Brocklehurst Shortlisted
NIHR128701 Development of a care pathway to address complex health and social care needs of older people who use drugs using candidacy theory and a co-production approach – Professor Catriona
Matheson Declined
NIHR128575 A randomised controlled trial evaluating the long-term effectiveness of Serenity Integrating Mentoring (SIM) compared to management as usual (MAU) – Dr Peter Fonagy Declined
NIHR128839 Optimising the use of National Clinical Audits across the NHS to improve patient outcomes – Dr Grazia Antonacci Declined
NIHR128365 Using evidence on public preferences for prioritisation to support local commissioning in the NHS: Development and validation of the Public Preferences and Priorities (PPP) evidence-based decision tool – Professor Jennifer Whitty Declined
NIHR128777 Defining and Embedding a Common Mental Health Dataset in all UK Clinical Trials – Professor Kathryn Abel Declined
NIHR128349 The use of locum doctors in the NHS: understanding and improving the safety and quality of care – Professor Kieran Walshe Shortlisted
Researcher-led Stage 1 Proposals: 18/153 Management of Chronic Pain Themed Call
NIHR128704 Chronic pain self-management in context: Identifying the impact of life-context on engagement with self-management – Professor Karen Rodham Declined
NIHR128671 A systematic review and meta-ethnography of how children with chronic non-cancer pain and their families experience and understand their condition, pain services and treatments – Dr
Emma France Shortlisted
NIHR128744 Clinical and cost effectiveness of an intervention to facilitate patient-led follow-on support groups (FSG) to maintain effects of pain management programmes (PMP) – Dr Penny Whiting Declined