Date 17th September 2020
Venue Microsoft Teams Meeting
Present Members
Jo Rycroft-Malone Chair
Matt Sutton Deputy Chair
Sarah Alderson
Chris Bojke
Andrew Booth
Jennifer Bostock
Kath Checkland
Peter Coventry
Sandra Duggan
Sarah Jane Fenton
Bernard Gudgin
Jill Maben
Rachel Meacock
Mark Pearson
Julius Sim
Carl Thompson
Louella Vaughan
Fiona Verity
Alan Watkins
Robina Mir
Secretariat
Stephanie Garfield-Birkbeck
Suzy Hopper
Lisa Stockwell
Ruth Challis
Ricky Piper
Tara Lamont
Apologies
Kevin Brazil
Kamlesh Khunti
Observers
Andrew Farmer
Geraldine MacDonald
Lizzie Coates
Helen Fisher
Seb Hinde
Toqir Mukhtar
Claire Gregory
Claire Helm
Lucy Holmes
Quoracy Information
Voting members: 20 (Quoracy = 13 = 66%)
Voting members present on Day 1: 18 (90%)
This figure does not include Robina Mir as she did not vote due to this being her first attendance at a Committee Meeting.
Funding Committee Comments Day One
19/94 Perinatal Mental Health
NIHR130810 – Making routine clinical meetings in perinatal mental health services therapeutically effective – adaptation and implementation of DIALOG+ for patients with perinatal psychosis (Perinatal D+) (Nikolina Jovanovic)
Chair: Jo Rycroft-Malone
Declared a conflict and left the room: Matt Sutton, Rachel Meacock
Decision: Declined
19/95 Solid Organ Donation
NIHR130902 – Paediatric Organ Donation from Paediatric Intensive Care Units: Potential, Practice, Preference, Perceptions. (PODPPPP) (Tracy Long-Sutehall)
Chair: Jo Rycroft-Malone
Declared a conflict and left the room: Sarah-Jane Fenton
Decision: Revise and Resubmit
NIHR130881 – Identifying the optimal model for the delivery of organ perfusion technology for solid organ transplantation in the UK (Gabriel Oniscu)
Chair: Jo Rycroft-Malone
Declared a conflict and left the room: None
Decision: Decline
19/118 Non-medical Workforce
NIHR131254 – Realist Evaluation: System and Patient Outcomes of Non-medical workforce Service models within urgent and Emergency care ("RESPONSE"). (Adrian Edwards)
Chair: Jo Rycroft-Malone
Declared a conflict and left the room: Jennifer Bostock, Jill Maben, Fiona Verity, Alan Watkins
Decision: Decline
NIHR131356 – Implementation of the non-medical practitioner workforce into the urgent and emergency care system skill-mix in England: a mixed methods study of configurations and impact. (Mary Halter)
Chair: Jo Rycroft-Malone
Declared a conflict and left the room: Jill Maben
Decision: Fund with changes
NIHR130989 –Exploring non-medical practitioner roles in the Emergency Department: impact on patients, workforce, and performance. (Suzanne Mason)
Chair: Jo Rycroft-Malone
Declared a conflict and left the room: Sarah Alderson, Chris Bojke, Andrew Booth, Jill Maben, Lizzie Coates
Decision: Decline
20/12 Low Calorie Diets
NIHR131650 – A Qualitative and Economic Evaluation of the NHS Low Calorie Diet Programme for People with Type 2 Diabetes - REBALANCED (low-caloRie diEt for diaBetes: quALitAtive and ecoNomiC Evaluation to inform commissioning Decision-making). (Leah Avery)
Chair: Matt Sutton
Declared a conflict and left the room: Kamlesh Khunti, Jo Rycroft-Malone, Andrew Booth, Peter Coventry, Jennifer Bostock, Mark Pearson, Chris Bojke, Seb Hinde, Lizzie Coates, Andrew Farmer
Decision: Decline
NIHR132075 – A coproduced mixed method evaluation of the NHS England low calorie diet implementation pilot. (Louisa Ells)
Chair: Matt Sutton
Declared a conflict and left the room: Kamlesh Khunti, Jo Rycroft-Malone, Andrew Booth, Peter Coventry, Jennifer Bostock, Mark Pearson, Sarah Alderson, Chris Bojke, Seb Hinde, Lizzie Coates,
Andrew Farmer, Robina Mir
Decision: Fund with changes
NIHR131681 – Realist evaluation of the Acceptability and Cost-Effectiveness of LC TDR pilot (RACE). (Susan Jebb)
Chair: Matt Sutton
Declared a conflict and left the room: Andrew Booth, Jennifer Bostock, Jo Rycroft-Malone, Kamlesh Khunti, Peter Coventry, Mark Pearson, Chris Bojke, Seb Hinde, Lizzie Coates, Andrew Farmer,
Robina Mir
Decision: Decline
NIHR131834 – Evaluation of the NHS low energy diet pilots in primary care. (Emma Baldry)
Chair: Matt Sutton
Declared a conflict and left the room: Peter Coventry, Mark Pearson, Jo Rycroft-Malone, Kamlesh Khunti, Jennifer Bostock, Andrew Booth, Chris Bojke, Seb Hinde, Lizzie Coates, Andrew Farmer
Decision: Decline
20/35 Spring Invitation – Straight to Stage 2 Proposals
NIHR131780 – Realising the potential: volunteering in health and social care. (Angela Ellis Paine)
Chair: Jo Rycroft-Malone
Declared a conflict and left the room: Sarah-Jane Fenton, Jennifer Bostock
Decision: Decline
NIHR131848 – i-Minds: A digital intervention to improve mental health and interpersonal resilience for young people who have experienced online sexual abuse - a non-randomised feasibility study with a mixed-methods design (Sandra Bucci)
Chair: Jo Rycroft-Malone
Declared a conflict and left the room: Kath Checkland, Rachel Meacock, Matt Sutton
Decision: Fund with changes
NIHR131884 – Improving access to cardiac rehabilitation for people with heart failure: implementation of a homebased service in the NHS. (Hasnain Dalal)
Chair: Jo Rycroft-Malone
Declared a conflict and left the room: Sarah Alderson, Chris Bojke, Peter Coventry, Seb Hinde, Mark Pearson, Sarah-Jane Fenton
Decision: Decline
NIHR132080 – A realist evaluation of the Living Well with Arthritis Services for NHS patients considering hip or knee replacement. (Andrew Moore)
Chair: Jo Rycroft-Malone
Declared a conflict and left the room: Andrew Booth, Mark Pearson, Andrew Farmer (observer)
Decision: Decline
NIHR132029 – Resilience and mental health of COVID-19 frontline health and social care workers: Evidence Reviews, learning froM OtheR health Emergencies (RECOVER-more). (Alex Pollock)
Chair: Jo Rycroft-Malone
Declared a conflict and left the room: Andrew Booth
Decision: Decline
Summary
| Proposal | Title | Outcome |
|---|---|---|
| 19/94 Perinatal Mental Health | ||
| NIHR130810 | Making routine clinical meetings in perinatal mental health services therapeutically effective – adaptation and implementation of DIALOG+ for patients with perinatal psychosis (Perinatal D+) (Nikolina Jovanovic) | Decline |
| 19/95 Solid Organ Donation | ||
| NIHR130902 | Paediatric Organ Donation from Paediatric Intensive Care Units: Potential, Practice, Preference, Perceptions. (PODPPPP) (Tracy Long-Sutehall) | Revise and resubmit |
| NIHR130881 | Identifying the optimal model for the delivery of organ perfusion technology for solid organ transplantation in the UK (Gabriel Oniscu) | Decline |
| 19/118 Non-medical Workforce | ||
| NIHR131254 | Realist Evaluation: System and Patient Outcomes of Non-medical workforce Service models within urgent and Emergency care ("RESPONSE"). (Adrian Edwards) | Decline |
| NIHR131356 | Implementation of the non-medical practitioner workforce into the urgent and emergency care system skill-mix in England: a mixed methods study of configurations and impact. (Mary Halter) | Fund with changes |
| NIHR130989 | Exploring non-medical practitioner roles in the Emergency Department: impact on patients, workforce, and performance. (Suzanne Mason) | Decline |
| 20/12 Low Calorie Diets | ||
| NIHR131650 | A Qualitative and Economic Evaluation of the NHS Low Calorie Diet Programme for People with Type 2 Diabetes - REBALANCED (low-caloRie diEt for diaBetes: quALitAtive and ecoNomiC Evaluation to inform commissioning Decision-making). (Leah Avery) | Decline |
| NIHR132075 | A coproduced mixed method evaluation of the NHS England low calorie diet implementation pilot. (Louisa Ells) | Fund with changes |
| NIHR131681 | Realist evaluation of the Acceptability and Cost-Effectiveness of LC TDR pilot (RACE). (Susan Jebb) | Decline |
| NIHR131834 | Evaluation of the NHS low energy diet pilots in primary care. (Emma Baldry) | Decline |
| 20/35 Spring Invitation – Straight to Stage 2 Proposals | ||
| NIHR131780 | Realising the potential: volunteering in health and social care. (Angela Ellis Paine) | Decline |
| NIHR131848 | i-Minds: A digital intervention to improve mental health and interpersonal resilience for young people who have experienced online sexual abuse - a non-randomised feasibility study with a mixed-methods design (Sandra Bucci) | Fund with changes |
| NIHR131884 | Improving access to cardiac rehabilitation for people with heart failure: implementation of a homebased service in the NHS. (Hasnain Dalal) | Decline |
| NIHR132080 | A realist evaluation of the Living Well with Arthritis Services for NHS patients considering hip or knee replacement. (Andrew Moore) | Decline |
| NIHR132029 | Resilience and mental health of COVID-19 frontline health and social care workers: Evidence Reviews, learning froM OtheR health Emergencies (RECOVER-more). (Alex Pollock) | Decline |