Minutes of the March 2020 Meeting
Date Postponed from March 15th 2020
Venue Online meeting
Present members
Rebecca Randell Chair
Victoria Tzortziou-Brown Deputy Chair
Alison Allam
Katja Behrendt
Rebecca Fisher
Sue Jordan
Holly Nelson-Becker
Silviya Nikolova
Adam Noble
Linda Parton
Carol Rivas
Victoria Tatton
Louise Wallace
Apologies
Peter Brindle
Stephen Bradley
Mona Kanaan
Tiritega Mawaka
James Rimmer
Adele Webb (swapped to Researcher-Led for this round to assist with a high number of applications)
Charlotte Williams
Secretariat
Suzy Hopper
Lisa Stockwell
Ricky Piper
Steph Garfield-Birkbeck
Jo Nurse
In attendance Nil
Observers: Dawn Dowding – first meeting as a committee member - did not participate.
Committee Comments
19/118 Non-medical workforce
NIHR131376 – Understanding the utilisation and effectiveness of the non-medical workforce in urgent and emergency care settings. A realist evaluation’. (Professor Alison Leary)
Chair: Rebecca Randell
Conflict: none
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and declined
Decision: Decline
NIHR131254 - Realist Evaluation: System and Patient Outcomes of Non-medical workforce Service models within urgent and Emergency care ("RESPONSE"). (Professor Adrian Edwards)
Chair: Rebecca Randell
Conflict: Sue Jordan
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and shortlisted
Decision: Shortlist
NIHR131356 - Implementation of the non-medical practitioner workforce into the urgent and emergency care system skill-mix in England: a mixed methods study of configurations and impact. (Dr Mary Halter)
Chair: Rebecca Randell
Conflict: None
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and shortlisted
Decision: Shortlist
NIHR130989 – Exploring non-medical practitioner roles in the Emergency Department: impact on patients, workforce, and performance. (Professor Suzanne Mason)
Chair: Victoria Tzortziou-Brown
Conflict: Rebecca Randell
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and shortlisted
Decision: Shortlist
NIHR131019 – Implementation, Interaction and Core Outcomes for Non-Medical Workforce Initiatives in Emergency Care Teams (INTERCONECT). (Associate Professor Sarah Voss)
Chair: Victoria Tzortziou-Brown
Conflict: Stephen Bradley, Dawn Dowding, Rebecca Randell
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and declined
Decision: Decline
19/94 Perinatal Mental Health call
NIHR130575 – Optimising delivery of NHS preconception care and digital interventions for women with serious mental illness of childbearing age. (Dr Abigail Easter)
Chair: Victoria Tzortziou-Brown
Conflict: Rebecca Randell
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and declined
Decision: Decline
NIHR131026 – The 'EMPoWER' Study: EMotional and Psychological Wellbeing in Parents of EaRly babies. (Dr Eilis Kennedy)
Chair: Rebecca Randell
Conflict: none
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and declined
Decision: Decline
NIHR130619 – An evaluation of models of care, best practice and care pathways for drug dependent women and their infants, from preconception to 24 months postnatal. (Dr Polly Radcliffe)
Chair: Rebecca Randell
Conflict: Dawn Dowding
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and shortlisted
Decision: Shortlist
NIHR130857 – Research Evaluation of Preconception support Of Women Experiencing severe or complex mental health conditions and their Relatives (REPOWER). (Dr Katherine Morley)
Chair: Rebecca Randell
Conflict: None
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and declined
Decision: Decline
NIHR130944 – Using implementation science to achieve scalability and sustainability for a programme to manage post-traumatic stress disorder in the maternity workforce. (Professor Pauline Slade)
Chair: Rebecca Randell
Conflict: none
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and declined
Decision: Decline
NIHR130810 –Making routine clinical meetings in perinatal mental health services therapeutically effective – adaptation and implementation of DIALOG+ for patients with perinatal psychosis (Perinatal D+). (Dr Nikolina Jovanovic)
Chair: Rebecca Randell
Conflict: none
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and shortlisted
Decision: Shortlist
19/142 Liver Disease
NIHR130799 – Reducing ALD admissions in primary care alcohol clinic – RADICAL. (Professor Mark Thursz)
Chair: Rebecca Randell
Conflict: Katja Behrendt
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and declined
Decision: Decline
NIHR131043 – Impact of current hospital-based strategies on avoidable mortality in alcohol-related liver disease: A mixed-methods study. (Dr Kate Fleming)
Chair: Rebecca Randell
Conflict: none
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and declined
Decision: Decline
19/95 Solid Organ Replacement
NIHR130902 – Paediatric Organ Donation from Paediatric Intensive Care Units: Potential, Practice, Preference, Perceptions. (PODPPPP). (Dr Tracy Long-Sutehall)
Chair: Rebecca Randell
Conflict: Carol Rivas
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and shortlisted
Decision: Shortlist
NIHR130881 – Identifying the optimal model for the delivery of organ perfusion technology for solid organ transplantation in the UK. (Mr Gabriel Oniscu)
Chair: Rebecca Randell
Conflict: none
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and shortlisted
Decision: Shortlist
SUMMARY
19/118 Non-medical workforce
| Reference | Proposal title | Outcome |
|---|---|---|
| NIHR131376 | Understanding the utilisation and effectiveness of the non-medical workforce in urgent and emergency care settings. A realist evaluation’. (Professor Alison Leary) | Decline |
| NIHR131254 | Realist Evaluation: System and Patient Outcomes of Non-medical workforce Service models within urgent and Emergency care ("RESPONSE"). (Professor Adrian Edwards) | Shortlist |
| NIHR131356 | Implementation of the non-medical practitioner workforce into the urgent and emergency care system skill-mix in England: a mixed methods study of configurations and impact. (Dr Mary Halter) | Shortlist |
| NIHR130989 | Exploring non-medical practitioner roles in the Emergency Department: impact on patients, workforce, and performance. (Professor Suzanne Mason) | Shortlist |
| NIHR131019 | Implementation, Interaction and Core Outcomes for Non-Medical Workforce Initiatives in Emergency Care Teams (INTERCONECT). (Associate Professor Sarah Voss) | Decline |
19/146 Perinatal Mental Health
| Reference | Proposal description | Outcome |
|---|---|---|
| NIHR130575 | Optimising delivery of NHS preconception care and digital interventions for women with serious mental illness of childbearing age. (Dr Abigail Easter) | Decline |
| NIHR131026 | The 'EMPoWER' Study: EMotional and Psychological Wellbeing in Parents of EaRly babies. (Dr Eilis Kennedy) | Decline |
| NIHR130619 | An evaluation of models of care, best practice and care pathways for drug dependent women and their infants, from preconception to 24 months postnatal. (Dr Polly Radcliffe) | Shortlist |
| NIHR130857 | Research Evaluation of Preconception support Of Women Experiencing severe or complex mental health conditions and their Relatives (REPOWER). (Dr Katherine Morley) | Decline |
| NIHR130944 | Using implementation science to achieve scalability and sustainability for a programme to manage post traumatic stress disorder in the maternity workforce. (Professor Pauline Slade) | Decline |
| NIHR130810 | Making routine clinical meetings in perinatal mental health services therapeutically effective – adaptation and implementation of DIALOG+ for patients with perinatal psychosis (Perinatal D+). (Dr Nikolina Jovanovic) | Shortlist |
19/142 Liver Disease
| Reference | Proposal Description | Outcome |
|---|---|---|
| NIHR130799 | Reducing ALD admissions in primary care alcohol clinic – RADICAL. (Professor Mark Thursz) | Decline |
| NIHR131043 | Impact of current hospital-based strategies on avoidable mortality in alcohol-related liver disease: A mixed-methods study. (Dr Kate Fleming) | Decline |
19/95 Solid Organ Replacement
| Reference | Proposal description | Outcome |
|---|---|---|
| NIHR130902 | Paediatric Organ Donation from Paediatric Intensive Care Units: Potential, Practice, Preference, Perceptions. (PODPPPP). (Dr Tracy Long-Sutehall) | Shortlist |
| NIHR130881 | Identifying the optimal model for the delivery of organ perfusion technology for solid organ transplantation in the UK. (Mr Gabriel Oniscu) | Shortlist |