Minutes of the June 2019 Meeting (Day 1)
Date: Wednesday 19th June 2019
Venue: Kensington Suite, Millennium Gloucester Hotel, London
Present
Members
- Peter Brindle (Chair)
- Judith Smith (Deputy Chair)
- Alison Allam
- Jan Filochowski
- Sue Jordan
- Mona Kanaan
- Richard McNally
- Holly Nelson-Becker
- Adam Noble
- Linda Parton
- James Rimmer
- Carol Rivas
- Sasha Shepperd
- Victoria Tatton
- Lois Thomas
- Carl Thompson
- Victoria Tzortziou Brown
- Charlotte Williams
- Iestyn Williams
Apologies
- Rebecca Fisher
- Nicola Hilton
- Carmel Hughes
- Suzanne Ii
- Umesh Kadam
- Tiritega Mawaka
- Silviya Nikolova
- Elizabeth Wade
- Adele Webb
Secretariat
- Steph Garfield-Birkbeck
- Suzy Hopper
- Julie Daniels
- Ricky Piper
In attendance
Nil
Observers
Nil
Quoracy Information
Voting members: 27 (Quoracy = 18)
Voting members present at meeting: 18 (67%)
19/16 Digital Technologies
129410 - Impact of an app in optimising antibiotic prescribing in young children by influencing parental health seeking behaviour (Paul Little)
Chair: Peter Brindle
Conflict: None
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and declined.
Decision: Declined
129344 - EQUIPOISE Evolving the QUIPP App for preterm labOur: Implementing at ScalE (Andrew Shennan)
Chair: Peter Brindle
Conflict: Adam Noble
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and declined.
Decision: Declined
128947 - Can Machine Learning improve the identification of hospital patients at risk of deterioration and death, using digitally available information in real time, whilst improving staff utilisation? (Thomas Daniels)
Chair: Peter Brindle
Conflict: None
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and shortlisted
Decision: Shortlisted
129313 - A framework for the evaluation of automated diagnostic chatbots (Ben Goldacre)
Chair: Peter Brindle
Conflict: Sasha Shepperd
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and shortlisted
Decision: Shortlisted
129082 - Digital alerting to improve sepsis detection in English NHS trusts (Ceire Costelloe)
Chair: Peter Brindle
Conflict: Sasha Shepperd
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and shortlisted
Decision: Shortlisted
129481 - Personalised Health Forecasting tools for Joint Replacement Outcomes (PHR-JR tools): two-parallel RCTs in a home and clinic setting (Jeremy Wilkinson)
Chair: Peter Brindle
Conflict: None
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and shortlisted
Decision: Shortlisted
129409 - Hospital Mortality Monitoring and Predictive Analytics (Sumi Helal)
Chair: Peter Brindle
Conflict: None
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and declined.
Decision: Declined
129295 - Meeting patients’ changing needs along the care pathway: a feasibility study of an online cancer site–specific and holistic needs assessment. (ISHARE-PBC) (Veronica Nanton)
Chair: Peter Brindle
Conflict: Sasha Shepperd
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and declined.
Decision: Declined
129246 - Drivers and barriers of adoption of robotic surgery in patients with prostate, lung and bowel cancer: Economic study to evaluate, cost to the society if minimally invasive surgery was widely adopted across these cancer groups (Naeem Soomro)
Chair: Peter Brindle
Conflict: Richard McNally
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and declined.
Decision: Declined
129395 - Evaluation of a digital app to support nutrition monitoring in gastroenterology patients (Darren Greenwood)
Chair: Peter Brindle
Conflict: Mona Kanaan, Carl Thompson
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and declined.
Decision: Declined
129413 - Evaluation of factors affecting the implementation and equity of uptake of synchronous home and mobile video outpatient consultations: a mixed methods study in three hospitals in England (Richard Lilford)
Chair: Peter Brindle
Conflict: Mona Kanaan, Judith Smith, Iestyn Williams
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and declined.
Decision: Declined
129157 - ASSIST (ASSessing the Impact of online postal self-sampling for STIs wiThin the UK) (Fiona Burns)
Chair: Peter Brindle
Conflict: Iestyn Williams, Judith Smith
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and shortlisted
Decision: Shortlisted
129173 - Mainstreaming Video Consultations - a multi-site case study of the routinisation, scale-up, spread and sustainability of virtual online consultations for marginalised and underserved groups (Sara Shaw)
Chair: Peter Brindle
Conflict: Judith Smith, Adam Noble
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and declined.
Decision: Declined
129215 Timely digital access for patients living with long-term conditions to their specialist clinical teams: informing service change (Frances Griffiths)
Chair: Peter Brindle
Conflict: Judith Smith, Iestyn Williams
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and shortlisted
Decision: Shortlisted
129294 - e-MDTs: Exploring the challenges of implementation, spread and scale-up of a digital solution for multi-disciplinary team meetings for cancer care (Trisha Greenhalgh)
Chair: Peter Brindle
Conflict: Judith Smith
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and declined.
Decision: Declined
129339 - Digital health solutions for complex epilepsy: a theory-driven evaluation (Chrysanthi Papoutsi)
Chair: Peter Brindle
Conflict: none
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and declined.
Decision: Declined
129110 - Mainstreaming digital pathology: A regional case study of the implementation, routinisation, spread, scale-up and sustainability of whole slide imaging (WSI) and related technological innovations in clinical histopathology services (Trisha Greenhalgh)
Chair: Peter Brindle
Conflict: none
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and declined.
Decision: Declined
129483 - Evaluating the safety and patient benefits of an AI Command Centre in the UK NHS (Owen Johnson)
Chair: Peter Brindle
Conflict: Carl Thompson
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and shortlisted
Decision: Shortlisted
129137 - Exploring, testing and implementing a learning health care system in IAPT (Peter Bower)
Chair: Peter Brindle
Conflict: Mona Kanaan
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and declined.
Decision: Declined
128711 - Co-produced Implementation of a Multi-morbidity Digital Intervention: a Realist Evaluation (Theodoros Arvanitis)
Chair: Peter Brindle
Conflict: Umesh Kadam
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and declined.
Decision: Declined
128640 - Evaluating the feasibility and impact of a postnatal sepsis DAISI (digital animation in service improvement); a mixed methods study (Melanie Cooper)
Chair: Peter Brindle
Conflict: None
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and declined.
Decision: Declined
129425 - Implementation of a community based early cancer detection programme: “i-REACT” – a web-enabled cancer symptom checker (Kenneth Muir)
Chair: Peter Brindle
Conflict: None
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and declined.
Decision: Declined
129450 - Enabling Participation with Commercially Available Digital Assistive Technology (EP-CADAT). An intervention to optimise the selection and adoption of enabling digital technologies – a feasibility study with people living with neurological conditions (Duncan Pentland)
Chair: Peter Brindle
Conflict: None
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and shortlisted
Decision: Shortlisted
129024 - Developing a Blueprint to optimise successful engagement with patient portals among older adults: an implementation study in three Global Digital Exemplar acute NHS Trusts (Zarnie Khadjesari)
Chair: Peter Brindle
Conflict: None
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and declined.
Decision: Declined
Minutes of the June 2019 Meeting (Day 2)
Date: Thursday 20th June 2019
Venue: Kensington Suite, Millennium Gloucester Hotel, London
Present
Members
- Peter Brindle (Chair)
- Judith Smith (Deputy Chair)
- Alison Allam
- Jan Filochowski
- Sue Jordan
- Umesh Kadam
- Mona Kanaan
- Tiritega Mawaka
- Richard McNally
- Holly Nelson-Becker
- Adam Noble
- Linda Parton
- Carol Rivas
- Sasha Shepperd
- Victoria Tatton
- Carl Thompson
- Adele Webb
- Charlotte Williams
- Iestyn Williams
Apologies
- Rebecca Fisher
- Nicola Hilton
- Carmel Hughes
- Suzanne Ii
- Silviya Nikolova
- James Rimmer
- Lois Thomas
- Victoria Tzortziou Brown
- Elizabeth Wade
Secretariat
- Steph Garfield-Birkbeck
- Suzy Hopper
- Lisa Stockwell
- Ricky Piper
In attendance
Nil
Observers
Nil
Quoracy Information
Voting members: 27 (Quoracy = 18)
Voting members present at meeting: 18 (67%)
Introduction to call 18/175 Precision Medicine
129224 - Improving the identification of familial hypercholesterolaemia through introduction of genetic testing in primary care (Nadeem Qureshi)
Chair: Peter Brindle
Conflict: Umesh Kadam, Mona Kanaan, Judith Smith
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and shortlisted
Decision: Shortlisted
Introduction to call 19/14 Community health and care services to support people with learning disabilities and behaviour that challenges and their families and carers
129577 - Mapping and Evaluating Services for Children with Learning Disabilities and Behaviours that Challenge (Richard Hastings)
Chair: Peter Brindle
Conflict: Judith Smith, Lois Thomas, Iestyn Williams
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and shortlisted
Decision: Shortlisted
129491 - Supporting family and professional carers to provide appropriate care and support for older learning disabled people with behaviours that challenge (Sara Ryan)
Chair: Peter Brindle
Conflict: None
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and shortlisted
Decision: Shortlisted
129538 - Clinical and cost effectiveness of models of supported living for young people and adults with intellectual disabilities and behaviour that challenges: a multi method investigation (Angela Hassiotis)
Chair: Peter Brindle
Conflict: Carol Rivas, Lois Thomas
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and shortlisted
Decision: Shortlisted
129270 - Keeping people with learning disabilities with behaviour that challenges in the community - qualitative thematic research exploring successful components of a good community support model (Satheesh Gangadharan)
Chair: Peter Brindle
Conflict: Adam Noble
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and declined.
Decision: Declined
129705 - Shared Lives for people with a learning disability: a realist evaluation (ShaRE) (Nadia Brookes)
Chair: Peter Brindle
Conflict: None
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and shortlisted
Decision: Shortlisted
Introduction to Call 18/174 End of Life Care
128799 - End of life care in care homes: supporting the workforce and reducing hospitalisations (Liz Forbat)
Chair: Peter Brindle
Conflict: None
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and shortlisted
Decision: Shortlisted
129368 - Inequalities in end of life trajectories and palliative care: a mixed-methods study using real-world NHS data and qualitative interviews (Daniel Prieto-Alhambra)
Chair: Peter Brindle
Conflict: Richard McNally
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and declined.
Decision: Declined
129096 – Right care, right place, right time for people with learning disabilities in the last year of their life: Investigating end of life care provision, trajectory, needs and inequalities (Irene Tuffrey-Wijne)
Chair: Peter Brindle
Conflict: None
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and shortlisted
Decision: Shortlisted
129171 - Electronic Palliative Care Co-ordination Systems (EPaCCS) in end of life care: evaluating their implementation and optimising future service provision (Matthew Allsop)
Chair: Peter Brindle
Conflict: None
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and shortlisted
Decision: Shortlisted
129190 - Supporting bereaved families after critical illness: understanding the outcomes and needs of bereaved family members to develop person-centred support interventions (Nazir Lone)
Chair: Peter Brindle
Conflict: None
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and shortlisted
Decision: Shortlisted
129213 - End of Life Care for Infants, Children and Young People: a mixed methods evaluation of current practice in England and Wales (Lorna Fraser)
Chair: Peter Brindle
Conflict: Mona Kanaan, Richard McNally
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and shortlisted
Decision: Shortlisted
129263 - Promoting competence, confidence and well-being at work in care staff providing end-of-life care for care home residents and their families using theory and research to optimise intervention development (Karen Spilsbury)
Chair: Peter Brindle
Conflict: Carl Thompson
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and declined.
Decision: Declined
129299 - A realist evaluation of advance care planning in perinatal settings: what works, for who, in which circumstances? (Karen Shaw)
Chair: Peter Brindle
Conflict: Judith Smith, Iestyn Williams
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and declined.
Decision: Declined
129312 - Supporting inter-professional working and collaborative planning in end of life care, for patient benefit, in the delivery of a Shared Palliative Care Plan (Katie Brittain)
Chair: Peter Brindle
Conflict: Richard McNally, Lois Thomas, Mona Kanaan
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and declined.
Decision: Declined
129131 - Clusters of causes of death: a national evaluation study of patterns, associated factors and care and cost outcomes (Wei Gao)
Chair: Peter Brindle
Conflict: None
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and declined.
Decision: Declined
129403 - Scoping, Design and Feasibility of a model of End-of-life Care in the Emergency Department (EEDTrak) (Cara Bailey)
Chair: Peter Brindle
Conflict: Judith Smith
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and declined.
Decision: Declined